Disinfecting wipes seem like a simple way to bring a dirty surface back to life. But depending on who is present – especially young children – their use may do more harm than good.
Sales of disinfectant wipes skyrocketed in the early days of the pandemic. They are practical, but often excessive for a simple cleaning job.
“Products labeled as disinfectants are not just cleaners,” said Catherine Roberts of Consumer Reports. “They also contain pesticides and, as such, require more careful handling than would be expected for a product that frequently appears on the back. » lists of school supplies.
In many disinfectant wipes, the active ingredients include quaternary ammonia compounds, or quats for short. They are effective at killing germs and are even used to control infections in some healthcare settings like hospitals. But quats can also trigger health problems like lung irritation, asthma, and allergies.
“These effects are of particular concern for children, because they breathe more air per pound of body weight than adults,” Roberts said. “No child should handle disinfectant wipes. “Keep out of reach of children” is written directly on the label.”
The American Cleaning Institute said in a statement to Consumer Reports: “Disinfectants are safe when used as directed. Disinfectants should not be applied by children. »
Most common household tasks require cleaning but not disinfection. Old-fashioned soap and water will do the trick.
If you like the convenience of wipes, there are many that clean, but don’t disinfect.
The Environmental Protection Agency has a list of cleaning products considered safer than others.
But some situations, like a stomach bug, require disinfection to prevent the spread of infection.
Clean and disinfect the surface thoroughly and allow sufficient time for the area to dry. Make sure young children do not stay in the room for any length of time. If your children’s school uses disinfecting wipes, you may want to ask if the wipes will be kept out of reach of children and that no child will use them, according to Consumer Reports.
If your child has a respiratory illness, such as asthma, your doctor may write a letter asking not to use wipes near your child.
